On her way home from Church, pious Christian Jenna J Ross is surprised to find her estranged lesbian step sister Bree Daniels loafing on the steps of their family home. The girls exchange greetings, and Bree tells Jenna she was kicked out of conversion therapy, for the same reason their parents kicked her out of the house. She can’t seem to pray the gay away. Jenna tells Bree to come inside the house, their parents are away at prayer camp. Bree takes a bath and Jenna wanders into the bathroom to check on her. Bree mischievously asks Jenna if she’ll wash her back, so Jenna sits on the edge of the tub and rubs a washcloth on Bree’s back as she innocently recounts news of their parents and encourages her to come to mass. Bree takes Jenna’s hand and thanks her for the support that will be her true salvation. They both hold the washcloth and Bree guides Jenna’s hand over her breasts to wash them as she reaches her hand between her legs to masturbate her pussy. She invites Jenna into the bath but Jenna pulls away and goes into her bedroom to pray. Bree follows her and takes away her prayer beads. Like a temptress she massages her vagina with the holy object. Jenna sets down her Bible determined to not give up on her sister’s lost soul, but Bree is committed to sinning. She creeps her hand up Jenna’s dress and kisses her. Jenna tells Bree it is wrong in the eyes of Jesus for two sisters to lay down together. Bree reminds her they are step sisters, and the Bible only speaks of men. She slips the dress off Jenna’s body and touches her sinful place, whispering that God loves everybody. Jenna begins to convulse with pleasure. When she remembers her pact with Jesus, Bree distracts her with fingers deep inside her pussy, edging her closer to orgasm. Bree shoves her onto the bed and takes off her lacey pink panties. She licks her pussy with her lesbian tongue till she swallows Jenna’s purity. Incurable Bree climbs on top of her good sister. She sits on her face and teaches her how to use her tongue. Jenna eats her sister till she trembles like the rapture from cumming. After that first encounter, Jenna can’t stop thinking about sinning with her lesbian sister Bree. She questions her faith and why Jesus has been silent. Jenna grapples with the guilt of copulating with her sister when Bree comes into her room with large dildo bearing the image of Christ on the cross. She makes her an offering. Jenna can worship Jesus or she can worship Bree. Jenna follows her sister and the mesmerizing crucifix dildo down to the living room. Bree puts the dildo in Jenna’s mouth and tells her to present herself. Jenna takes off her clothes in obedience, and lies on the floor with her legs splayed overhead. Bree plunges the crucifix dildo into her pussy and fucks her repeatedly while rubbing Jenna’s clit until she cums. Then Bree lets Jenna dominate her pussy with the crucifix dildo till she extracts her cum. The sisters take turns facesitting, then 69 till they twitch from their lesbian ministrations. Has Jenna truly abandoned her faith for her lesbian step sister Bree? Click to find out!